Not All Private Credit Is the Same: What the NAIC’s $1.21 Trillion Insurer Analysis Really Shows

The headline number is attention-grabbing: U.S. insurers held approximately $1.21 trillion in assets falling under a broad definition of private credit at year-end 2025.

But that number is not the most important takeaway from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners’ new analysis.

The more meaningful finding is that not all private credit presents the same risks, structures, transparency, or valuation challenges.

More than half of insurers’ broadly defined private-credit holdings consist of asset types with comparatively straightforward credit risks and a long history of regulatory monitoring. The NAIC’s primary focus is the remaining $544 billion held in privately rated bonds, business development companies, and private-credit funds—categories that may involve greater structural complexity or underlying exposure to alternative assets.

The report is not declaring that insurers hold $1.21 trillion in unusually risky investments. It is establishing a more precise framework for identifying where complexity resides and where closer attention may be warranted.

For insurers, financial-reporting professionals, auditors, and valuation teams, that distinction matters.

What the NAIC found

According to the NAIC Capital Markets Bureau, U.S. insurers held approximately $1.21 trillion in broadly defined private-credit assets at year-end 2025. That represented approximately:

  • 13% of insurers’ cash and invested assets

  • 21% of total bond holdings

The analysis divided those holdings into several categories:

  • $580 billion in private-placement bonds

  • $512 billion in privately rated bonds

  • $44 billion in bank loans identified as private credit

  • $42 billion in middle-market collateralized loan obligations

  • $32 billion in business development companies and private-credit funds

The NAIC removed identifiable overlap among categories when calculating the $1.21 trillion total.

Of that total, approximately $666 billion consisted of private-placement bonds, bank loans, and middle-market CLOs. Insurers have invested in these asset types for decades, and regulators have considerable experience monitoring them.

The remaining $544 billion—privately rated bonds, BDCs, and private-credit funds—is the NAIC’s primary area of focus. These assets represented approximately 6% of insurers’ cash and invested assets and 9% of total bond holdings.

Why the definition matters

There is no universally accepted definition of private credit.

Some market participants use the term primarily for direct lending. Others include private placements, bank loans, privately rated bonds, middle-market CLOs, BDCs, private-credit funds, and other debt-like investments that are not publicly issued or traded.

That creates a basic comparability problem.

Two institutions may report very different private-credit exposures—not necessarily because their portfolios differ substantially, but because they classify the assets differently.

A single headline number can therefore obscure important distinctions involving:

  • The instrument’s structure

  • Direct versus indirect borrower exposure

  • The availability of public information

  • Credit-rating practices

  • Secondary-market activity

  • Liquidity

  • Underlying collateral

  • Valuation inputs

  • Regulatory reporting classifications

The NAIC’s analysis attempts to bring greater precision to the discussion by identifying distinct categories rather than treating the entire market as one homogeneous asset class.

Why privately rated bonds are receiving particular attention

Privately rated bonds accounted for approximately $512 billion of the NAIC’s $544 billion focus area.

Unlike public ratings, private letter ratings are distributed only to the issuer and a specified group of investors. The underlying security may also have limited public disclosure concerning its collateral, structure, transaction mechanics, and credit risks.

The NAIC noted that limited public information and independent market evidence can make it more difficult to assess credit risk and determine an appropriate valuation.

The category has also evolved to include investments connected to alternative assets and more complex structures, including infrastructure debt, real-estate debt, asset-based finance, collateralized fund obligations, and rated feeder funds.

These structures are not automatically inappropriate or improperly valued. However, complexity can increase the importance of understanding:

  • What exposures ultimately support the investment

  • How cash flows move through the structure

  • Which parties provide ratings or valuations

  • What assumptions drive the reported value

  • Whether market evidence is observable

  • How liquidity and structural protections affect risk

  • Whether the documentation clearly supports the conclusion

The NAIC is pursuing initiatives intended to reduce what it describes as blind reliance on credit-rating-provider ratings, including a process for challenging ratings that regulators believe do not reasonably reflect risk and a due-diligence framework for rating providers.

The broader message is clear: a rating or classification should support analysis—not replace it.

What current performance indicators show

The NAIC report identifies a mixed picture rather than a simple warning of widespread deterioration.

As of the third quarter of 2025, private-credit non-accruals were below their 10-year average, according to data cited in the report. Default rates had also remained relatively stable across several borrower-size categories.

At the same time, regulators are monitoring several signals:

Payment-in-kind usage

Approximately 7% of private borrowers were using payment-in-kind features as of November 2025, above the decade average of approximately 6%.

PIK provisions allow interest to be added to the outstanding principal rather than paid in cash. This can provide borrowers with liquidity and may be included in a loan’s original structure.

However, when added later because a borrower cannot meet cash-interest obligations, PIK treatment may indicate financial stress. It can also delay a payment default or recognition of deterioration.

Context matters. The existence of a PIK feature does not automatically establish distress, but the reason for its use and the timing of any amendment may be important to the credit and valuation analysis.

Repeat defaults

The report states that a record 40% of default actions in 2025 involved issuers that had previously experienced a default action.

This suggests that a restructuring or distressed exchange does not necessarily resolve the underlying credit problem. Valuation teams may need to consider whether revised terms address the borrower’s fundamental capacity to repay or primarily defer the problem.

Limited experience through a severe downturn

Much of private credit’s growth occurred during a period of abundant capital, strong economic conditions, and relatively low default rates.

The NAIC therefore cautions that it remains uncertain how private-credit investments involving alternative underlying assets or more complex structures would perform during a prolonged and fully stressed credit cycle.

This is an observation about uncertainty—not a prediction of imminent failure.

Enhanced reporting is coming into focus

State insurance regulators adopted enhanced reporting disclosures in 2026 that will appear in insurers’ year-end 2026 annual-statement filings.

The new information is expected to help regulators distinguish more clearly among:

  • Rule 144A securities

  • Regulation D private placements

  • Other securities exempt from registration

  • Privately rated securities

  • Complex and alternative investment structures

The NAIC expects these disclosures to improve the identification and classification of private-credit exposure and refine future analysis.

For reporting and valuation teams, more granular classification may also create new questions:

  • Is the investment categorized consistently across internal and regulatory reporting?

  • Does the classification accurately reflect its underlying structure?

  • Can the team identify the ultimate credit exposure?

  • Are ratings, market data, and valuation assumptions sufficiently documented?

  • Can reported values be supported when observable market evidence is limited?

  • Are changes in structure, collateral, or borrower performance captured promptly?

Better data does not eliminate judgment. It makes the basis for that judgment more visible.

What this means for valuation teams

The NAIC report is primarily an exposure and classification analysis—not a new valuation standard.

Still, it highlights several considerations relevant to supportable valuation processes.

Classification should come before comparison

A broad private-credit label may not be specific enough to identify appropriate market references or valuation methods.

A direct corporate loan, a privately rated structured bond, a BDC investment, and a private-credit fund interest may all fall within a broad definition of private credit, but they do not necessarily share the same:

  • Cash-flow structure

  • Liquidity profile

  • Observable inputs

  • Credit protections

  • Market participants

  • Valuation methodology

  • Risk characteristics

Understanding the instrument is essential before selecting comparables or interpreting market data.

Complexity should be made understandable

Complexity is not itself evidence that a value is inappropriate. But the valuation file should clearly explain the structure, underlying exposure, significant assumptions, data sources, and methodology.

A reviewer should not have to reverse-engineer the investment before understanding how it was valued.

Ratings are one input

A public or private credit rating may provide useful information, but it should be considered alongside the instrument’s structure, borrower performance, market conditions, liquidity, collateral, and other relevant evidence.

The greater the opacity or complexity, the more important it becomes to understand what supports the rating and whether other information corroborates it.

Market signals require context

PIK usage, non-accrual status, amendments, distressed exchanges, and repeat defaults can all affect an investment’s risk profile.

None should be interpreted in isolation.

A PIK feature included at origination to support a growth strategy may carry different implications than one added because a borrower cannot make a cash-interest payment. Similarly, a restructuring that improves long-term repayment capacity differs from one that merely postpones a likely default.

Documentation becomes more important as observability decreases

When public disclosures are limited and secondary-market activity is sparse, the valuation may depend more heavily on unobservable inputs and professional judgment.

That increases the importance of documenting:

  • The instrument and its underlying exposures

  • The source and date of financial information

  • The selected methodology

  • Significant assumptions

  • Relevant market evidence

  • Changes from prior periods

  • Conflicting information

  • Review and approval

  • The rationale supporting the conclusion

Six questions firms should be prepared to answer

As regulatory reporting becomes more granular, firms holding complex private-credit investments should be prepared to answer:

  1. How is the investment classified, and does that classification reflect its underlying structure?

  2. What borrower, collateral, or fund exposures ultimately support the investment?

  3. What information supports the credit rating, and what independent evidence corroborates it?

  4. Which valuation inputs are observable, and which require significant judgment?

  5. Have changes in payment structure, liquidity, borrower performance, or market conditions been incorporated?

  6. Could an independent reviewer understand and reproduce the valuation using the documentation provided?

These questions do not presume that the investment is misclassified, unusually risky, or incorrectly valued. They help ensure that its complexity is understood and its reported value is supportable.

The broader takeaway

The NAIC’s analysis provides a useful correction to oversimplified discussions about insurer exposure to private credit.

The $1.21 trillion headline is important—but it does not tell the complete story.

More than half of that amount consists of familiar asset types with comparatively straightforward credit risks and a long history of regulatory oversight. The area receiving greater attention is the $544 billion in privately rated bonds, BDCs, and private-credit funds that may involve more complex structures, alternative underlying assets, lower transparency, or indirect borrower exposure.

The lesson is not that all private credit should be viewed the same way.

It is the opposite:

Sound oversight, reporting, and valuation begin with understanding exactly what the investment is.

Harvest helps financial-reporting professionals navigate complex and hard-to-price instruments through independent valuations, relevant market data, transparent methodologies, and clearly documented assumptions.

Need support understanding or valuing a complex private-credit investment? Contact Harvest Investments to learn how its valuation professionals can support your team.

Sources

  1. National Association of Insurance Commissioners, “NAIC Analysis Identifies and Categorizes Insurer Private Credit Investments,” November 5, 2026

  2. NAIC Capital Markets Bureau, “Private Credit Analysis of the U.S. Insurance Industry,” November 2026

  3. NAIC, “Private Credit and Insurance: A Data-Driven View from State Regulators”

Next
Next

You Received a Price. But Is It Reliable? What Firms Should Know About Broker Quotes and Third-Party Pricing